← All Reviews

Bourbon Review

Old Forester 1910

Old Fine Whisky — Double Barreled Kentucky Straight Bourbon · 93 Proof

Old Forester 1910 bottle
4 Buy This Bottle
Distillery Brown-Forman / Old Forester Origin Louisville, KY Type Double Barreled Straight Bourbon ABV 46.5% (93 proof) Price ~$45

⚑ Placeholder review — tasting notes to be updated after the pour.

The Story

The 1910 commemorates the year Old Forester introduced what they called "Old Fine Whisky" — a smoother, more refined expression created partly by accident when a batch couldn't be bottled on schedule and spent additional time in a second barrel. Rather than treating it as a problem, they recognized it as an improvement. The modern 1910 recreates that happy accident: standard Old Forester bourbon transferred to a second, heavily toasted (but uncharred) barrel for finishing. It's the most approachable expression in the Whiskey Row Series and one of the most food-friendly bourbons in the lineup.

Nose, Palate & Finish

Nose

Softer and rounder than the 1920 — the toasted barrel smooths things out considerably. Vanilla custard, baked apple, cinnamon, and a gentle oak warmth. There's a subtle maple syrup note and a faint nuttiness that makes this one very easy to sit with. Approachable but not boring.

Palate

Medium-bodied and silky. The double barrel treatment shows up clearly: the wood influence is present but softer and more integrated than a typical straight bourbon. Toasted coconut, caramel, baked pear, and a gentle cinnamon spice. Less intense than the 1920, more refined. A great sipping bourbon for people who find high-proof expressions a bit much.

Finish

Medium length, warm, and smooth. Toasted oak and vanilla carry through to the end with a mild sweetness that fades cleanly. Nothing abrupt — this one just quietly exits when it's done.

The Verdict

The 1910 is the sleeper of the Whiskey Row Series. It gets less attention than the 1920 but it's an excellent pour in its own right — particularly for anyone who wants something refined and food-friendly rather than bold and proof-forward. Pair it with dessert or drink it neat after dinner. At $45 it's an easy yes.