← All Reviews

Rye Whiskey Review · Buffalo Trace Antique Collection

Thomas H. Handy Sazerac Rye

Uncut, Unfiltered Straight Rye Whiskey — Annual Release

Thomas H. Handy Sazerac Rye bottle
5Worth Secondary Prices
Distillery Buffalo Trace Origin Frankfort, KY Type Barrel Proof Straight Rye Release 2025 ABV ~60–65% (varies by year) Price ~$150 retail (MSRP) / $400+ secondary

The Story

Thomas H. Handy is the rye version of George T. Stagg — barrel proof, unfiltered, dropped once a year as part of the BTAC lineup. It's only about six years old, which for barrel-proof rye is basically still a teenager, but the proof cranks up everything the mashbill's got — pepper, grain, all of it — into something way bigger than its age has any right to be. Named after the guy credited with inventing the Sazerac cocktail, which feels like a fitting flex.

Nose, Palate & Finish

Nose

Loud. Pepper, mint, and grain hit first, with the proof making sure you notice. It's a lot, but it's a good lot.

Palate

Serious rye spice right out of the gate — pepper, a sharp grainy bite, some heat from the proof. There's sweetness under there too, but you have to work for it a little.

Finish

Very long, spicy, and warm — the pepper and heat just keep going. The sweetness taps out early and leaves a dry, serious finish that lasts.

The Verdict

Handy is the reason rye deserves more respect than it gets. At full proof it's a lot to handle, but that's the point — one of the most interesting pours of the year. Don't skip it just because it's not bourbon.